Lord Foster, chair of Peers for Gambling Reform (PGR), has called for greater scrutiny of Pokémon trading cards, arguing that their resale value raises questions about whether certain purchases should fall within the UK’s gambling legislation.
The debate centres on the Gambling Act 2005 and its definition of items with monetary value. Foster believes that Pokémon cards can meet the definition of money’s worth because they have objectively measurable financial value and can be exchanged for cash through established secondary markets.
In a letter dated 21 July 2026, Foster questioned why collectible cards should be excluded from gambling legislation when some individual items command substantial prices. He argued that their commercial resale markets distinguish them from digital items obtained through video-game loot boxes.
The issue has gained attention alongside the growing popularity of Pokémon collecting, supported by online content creators and games such as Pokémon GO. Demand has also driven significant increases in collectible prices. One particularly notable example involved a collector in Woking who sold a Pokémon card collection for £1.56 million at auction.
Gambling Commission Rejects Automatic Classification
The Gambling Commission has rejected the argument that the possibility of reselling Pokémon cards automatically makes their purchase a form of gambling.
In a response dated 11 August, acting chief executive Sarah Gardner explained:
Secondary-market trading alone does not bring collectible cards or football stickers within the Gambling Act’s definition of gambling.
Sarah Gardner, Acting Chief Executive of the Gambling Commission
She also highlighted Parliament’s intention when establishing the legislation, arguing that products involving an element of chance during purchase were not necessarily intended to be covered by gambling regulation.
However, Gardner acknowledged that the regulator could investigate products incorporating gambling-like features into shopping platforms or other commercial experiences.
The Commission is not currently conducting specific regulatory activity concerning the purchase or trading of collectible cards and stickers.
Wider Debate Over Gambling-Like Mechanics
Foster’s concerns extend beyond physical trading cards. He has previously called for greater scrutiny of gambling-like mechanics in video games, particularly products involving randomised rewards.
The discussion is also relevant to the proposed EU Digital Fairness Act, which includes provisions addressing paid variable reward systems. These include loot boxes, prize wheels and collectible card packs offering randomised outcomes in exchange for money or paid virtual currency.
The UK Gambling Commission maintains that any expansion of its regulatory powers must be supported by legislation. Changes to the Gambling Act’s definitions would therefore require action from the government and Parliament.
The debate comes as the newly established Gambling Policy Commission begins reviewing the UK’s gambling legislation and considering whether broader legal reform is necessary.
Comments
This action can't be undone.